About David

Fifty years teaching engineers to understand structures

Dr David Brohn MBE PhD CEng FIStructE worked on the Sydney Opera House shells at Arup, tested their graduate intake, and spent the rest of his career fixing what that test revealed. His method is taught to consultancies, used in universities, and has been recognised by the Institution of Structural Engineers and by the Crown.

The record

  • MBE in the 2022 honours, invested February 2023
  • Institution of Structural Engineers President’s Award, 2015
  • Understanding Structural Analysis, first published 1984
  • Course commissioned by the Arup Partnership, early 1970s

The problem he set out to solve

In his first class at the newly formed Bristol Polytechnic in 1970, preparing students for the Institution’s Chartered Membership exam, David found they could run the calculations but could not say how the structure would behave. When the computer arrived in the mid-1980s it made the gap wider: the software produced answers, and the habit of checking them by eye disappeared.

He devised a test: a beam or frame, a load, and one question — sketch the bending moment diagram. No calculation. What it measures is whether you can see how the structure carries load. How the method works →

What the test found

Applied to three consecutive years of graduates entering the Arup Graduate School in the early 1970s, the mean score was 35%. Arup commissioned him to write the course that became Understanding Structural Behaviour, and it has run ever since.

Performance has not improved. His 2021 paper in The Structural Engineer reports a group of 23 delegates from Imperial, Cambridge, Bath, Bristol, Sheffield, UCL and others scoring a mean of 25%, with two of the simplest items — cantilevers — answered wrongly by about half the room.


50+

years teaching structural behaviour

35%

mean score, Arup graduates, early 1970s

1984

Understanding Structural Analysis, foreword by Sir Ove Arup

2nd

President’s Award ever made by the Institution, 2015


Why the method stands up

Four things a reader can check for themselves rather than take on trust.

Tested, not asserted

A measurement, taken three times

The claim is not that graduates are careless. It is a result: three consecutive intakes, the same twenty-item test, a mean of 35%. The test has since been used by universities and employers to measure the same thing.

Argued in print

Fifty years of publication

Papers in The Structural Engineer from 1977 onwards, including a 15-year study using the Arup graduate intake as its control group, and ‘Structural behaviour’ in September 2021, which published the recent scores in full.

Taken up by the Institution

From a paper to a qualification

In 2009 the Institution set up a committee under a past president, Dr Graham Owens, to improve the understanding of structural behaviour at undergraduate level. That work led to its Essential Knowledge Texts, its academics conference and the Certificate in Structural Behaviour — and the Institution now lists David’s course on its own site.

Recognised

By the Institution, and by the Crown

The President’s Award in 2015 — only the second the Institution had ever made — and the MBE in the 2022 honours, received at Windsor Castle in February 2023 for services to structural engineering.


In their words

“The President’s Award is to be presented to Dr David Brohn for his visionary approach to the education of students and graduates in structural engineering. For several decades, David’s ‘Brohn Test’ has been used by educators and employers to measure and embed an understanding of structural behaviour.”

Professor Tim Ibell, President of the Institution of Structural Engineers, 2015

“The increasing use of computers has to a great extent killed this understanding which is so essential for rescuing the art of structural design… We must be able to check that the output from the computer is correct.”

Sir Ove Arup, foreword to the first edition of Understanding Structural Analysis, 1984

The Institution describes the course as “a ten hour online training course originally commissioned by the Arup Partnership” and notes that the site is developed by Dr Brohn; it also states, plainly, that the course is not an Institution resource. The Institution runs the Certificate in Structural Behaviour; David’s courses prepare for it.


The career, in order

Arup, London

Design of the Sydney Opera House shells, followed by postgraduate study and a PhD at Leeds University.

1970

Bristol Polytechnic, teaching structures and preparing students for the Institution’s Chartered Membership exam. The first version of the test.

Early 1970s

Three years of Arup graduate intakes tested, mean score 35%. Arup commissions the two-day course.

1977

‘Teaching towards an improved understanding of structural behaviour’, with J. Cowan, in The Structural Engineer.

1984

Understanding Structural Analysis published, with a foreword by Sir Ove Arup.

1986

QSE Ltd founded, building analysis software on what the test showed about visual reasoning.

2005

Third edition of the textbook; the courses run in the UK, Denmark, India and Dubai.

2009

The Institution sets up its committee on understanding structural behaviour.

2015

President’s Award, presented by Professor Tim Ibell.

2023

MBE received from King Charles at Windsor Castle, 14 February.


What that work is now

The courses David ran in person are online, built around the same three-part solution: deflected shape, reactions, bending moment diagram — each one a check on the other two.

Understanding Structural Behaviour

The course Arup commissioned, now 16 video lessons with practice problems and worked solutions.

See the course →

Understanding Structural Analysis

The book, and the course that goes with it: the limits of computer analysis and the checks every result needs.

See the course →

The Brohn Test

Three frames from the test itself. Free, marked instantly, with David’s explanation of each.

Take the test →


From engineers who used it

The first chapter on qualitative analysis of Frames was a revelation. … My success in designing complex structures would not have been possible without the lessons I learned from your book.
AbhayFounder, Optimal Designs · M.Tech, IIT Bombay
For IStructE exam preparation, the course directly supports success by developing the exact skills needed for the institution's challenging design questions.
ObioraUnderstanding Structural Behaviour student
With most design done by software programs in today's industry, having this background knowledge will enable me to spot any mistakes produced by the computer software.
MikeRecent graduate

See where you stand

Three frames, marked straight away. It is the same test that produced the numbers above, and it is free.